Fourth Circuit rules 2–1 against Kalshi in Maryland, the third appeals court to reject its pre-emption case
A divided Fourth Circuit panel has upheld a Maryland judge's refusal to stop state gaming regulators enforcing their laws against Kalshi's sports event contracts. The two judges in the majority gave different reasons, and the third would have ruled for Kalshi. Three of the four federal appeals courts to decide the question have now gone against the exchange, while New Jersey's petition asking the Supreme Court to hear the issue is pending.
A divided panel of the US Court of Appeals for the Fourth Circuit has upheld a federal judge’s refusal to stop Maryland’s gaming regulators enforcing state law against Kalshi’s sports event contracts. In KalshiEX LLC v. Martin (No. 25-1892), decided on 17 November, the court affirmed the District of Maryland’s 1 August 2025 denial of a preliminary injunction in a one-line published per curiam opinion: “The judgment of the district court is AFFIRMED.”
Judges Roger Gregory and Stephanie Thacker made up the majority but wrote separate concurrences on different grounds. Judge DeAndrea Gist Benjamin dissented. The appeal was argued on 7 May 2026.
The ruling concerns a preliminary injunction, not the final merits. Kalshi filed the case on 21 April 2025, after receiving a cease-and-desist letter from Maryland’s gaming authorities, the opinion says, arguing that the Commodity Exchange Act (CEA) pre-empts Maryland’s sports-wagering laws as applied to trading on its CFTC-designated contract market (DCM).
Two routes to the same result
Judge Gregory did not decide whether Kalshi’s sports event contracts are “swaps”, the category over which the CEA gives the CFTC “exclusive jurisdiction” when traded on a DCM. “[E]ven assuming they are,” he wrote, “neither the Act nor the CFTC’s implementation of it clearly establish that such contracts are entitled to trade on a DCM free from state gaming laws.”
His concurrence turns on the CEA’s “Special Rule” for event contracts involving gaming and the CFTC’s Rule 40.11, which bars DCMs from listing certain gaming contracts. Kalshi self-certifies its contracts, and the CFTC has not disapproved them. Judge Gregory said the fact that they continue to trade does not settle the question: “Kalshi’s argument ultimately asks us to treat the continued listing of its self-certified contracts as more legally significant than the text of the Special Rule and Rule 40.11. Neither Congress nor the CFTC has directed courts to do so.”
He noted that the CFTC’s March 2026 advance notice of proposed rulemaking and the amendments to Rule 40.11 it proposed three months later “remain pending and therefore do not alter the text of Rule 40.11 presently in force”. He also found no conflict pre-emption: Kalshi could comply with both regimes by “satisfying Maryland’s licensing requirements or declining to offer the individual contracts within the state”. He concluded: “Congress knows how to displace traditional state police powers when it chooses to do so. Here, it has not done so with the clarity our precedents require.”
Judge Thacker went further. In her view, Kalshi’s sports event contracts “are not swaps within the meaning of the CEA”, so they “lie beyond the exclusive regulatory authority” of the CFTC and “Maryland officials can co-regulate these contracts”. She said Kalshi’s reading of the swap definition “reaches an absurd result that would criminalize any sports bet placed in the United States — from Las Vegas casinos to local pool halls”. She added: “What is happening here is sports betting. … That is gambling, plain and simple.”
The dissent
Judge Benjamin would have ruled for Kalshi. “Because I think Kalshi’s sports-related event contracts are ‘swaps’ under the CEA, and because Congress has granted ‘exclusive jurisdiction’ over such swaps to the CFTC, I would vacate the district court’s denial of the preliminary injunction and remand for further proceedings,” she wrote. She found Maryland’s laws field pre-empted and did not reach conflict pre-emption. “Just because the CFTC hasn’t disapproved Kalshi’s sports-related contracts under its regulations, doesn’t mean Maryland can regulate Kalshi in its place.”
Where the appeals courts now stand
Judge Gregory’s concurrence lists the earlier appellate rulings. The Third Circuit found pre-emption in New Jersey’s case (KalshiEX v. Flaherty). The Sixth Circuit (KalshiEX v. Schuler, Ohio) and the Ninth Circuit (KalshiEX v. Assad, Nevada) found none. With Maryland, three of the four appeals courts to rule have now gone against Kalshi. We reported the Sixth Circuit decision in September and Kalshi’s petition for rehearing there in October.
New Jersey has already asked the Supreme Court to review the Third Circuit ruling. Its petition in Flaherty v. KalshiEX (No. 26-299) was filed on 2 September. According to the Supreme Court docket, Kalshi’s response is due on 7 December 2026 after two extensions, and the Court has not acted on the petition.
Maryland was supported on appeal by amicus briefs from Nevada, Ohio, 36 other states and the District of Columbia, as well as gaming industry, tribal, anti-gambling and other groups. Paradigm Operations and Underdog Sports Holding filed in support of Kalshi. The CFTC is not listed among the amici in the opinion.
Why it matters
- Three of the four appeals courts to rule have now rejected Kalshi’s pre-emption argument. Each appeals court that has rejected it has done so at the preliminary-injunction stage. The latest is a published decision.
- The majority did not agree on why. One judge assumed the contracts might be swaps and still found no clear pre-emption; the other said they are not swaps. That leaves two separate lines of reasoning for other courts, and for the Supreme Court if it takes the issue, to weigh.
- The CFTC’s rulemaking featured in the reasoning. Judge Gregory treated the Commission’s pending Rule 40.11 proposals, and the absence of any CFTC determination on Kalshi’s self-certified contracts, as leaving the question unsettled. The CFTC’s separate October proposal to define event contracts expressly as swaps, whose comment period ran until 18 November, is not cited in the opinions. The Commission’s release on that proposal says it would cover contracts “based on sports, politics, cultural, and weather-related events”.
- The question is now before the Supreme Court in New Jersey’s petition. The Fourth Circuit’s ruling arrives while that petition is pending, with Kalshi’s response due on 7 December.
What we are watching
- Whether Kalshi seeks rehearing en banc in the Fourth Circuit, as it did in the Sixth.
- Kalshi’s 7 December response to New Jersey’s Supreme Court petition, and whether the Court takes the case.
- Whether the CFTC adopts its swap-definition proposal after comments close, and how courts treat it if it does.
Sources
Checked on 18 November 2026 between 07:54 and 07:55 GMT (London time). No market prices or volumes are quoted in this story.
- US Court of Appeals for the Fourth Circuit, KalshiEX LLC v. Martin, No. 25-1892, published per curiam opinion, decided 17 Nov 2026 (argued 7 May 2026). Judge Gregory’s concurrence is at pp. 7–33, Judge Thacker’s at pp. 34–43 and Judge Benjamin’s dissent at pp. 44–59.
- Supreme Court of the United States, docket for Flaherty v. KalshiEX, LLC, No. 26-299, petition filed 2 Sep 2026.
- Commodity Futures Trading Commission, Release 9310-26, 9 Oct 2026.
News and information only, not investment advice. See our disclaimer.
Risk: Prediction markets carry risk. You can lose the money you stake, and these markets may be restricted or unlawful where you live.
Spotted an error? Email corrections@themidpointnews.com. See our editorial standards, including how we use AI and handle corrections.




